After regulators lost faith and depositors fled, Signature Bank were taken by the government on Sunday.
In an email statement Tuesday, the Department of Financial Services stated that “the bank failed to provide reliable data consistent with the expectations of the public,” and added that the decision was based on the current state of the bank. “The FDIC took possession of the bank Monday and handed it over to them. This was based on its current state and ability to conduct business in a safe, sound way.
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. took control of Signature and established a bridge bank for clients. According to one person familiar with the matter, the collapse was the third largest bank failure in US history. It followed a surge of customer withdrawals Friday that accounted for about 20% of the company’s deposits.
Joseph DePaolo, the former Chief Executive Officer, didn’t immediately reply to a request for comments. A representative from the bridge bank also did not respond.Barney Frank, a former US congressman, was on Signature’s board. He said that he had a different view on how things unfolded.
Frank stated in an interview that “I’m shocked” “That wasn’t my understanding of where they were.”
Frank stated that data about the bank’s balance sheets was volatile due to management dealing with outflows. However, executives were eventually able to understand the situation. Although he denied being directly involved in the discussions with regulators, he said that he was being briefed along with other members by executives.
Frank stated that “by Sunday morning, executives of the bank believed that they had satisfied data needs and had secured capital from the discount window or elsewhere.” Frank reiterated his belief that Monday would have been possible for the bank to open, but said that he was still unsure if the bank’s willingness and ability to work with crypto companies caused the bank to close.
Frank stated Monday that regulators wanted to “send a message to get people out of crypto,” in a Bloomberg radio interview. “We were chosen to be the poster child for this message.”According to the DFS, the decision had nothing to do crypto. They added that the agency has been “facilitating well-regulated crypto activities over several years and is a national example for regulating this space.”
Former congressman stated that he understood deposit outflows had stabilized as of Sunday morning. The DFS said that there were “significant withdrawal requests still being pending and increasing” throughout the weekend.
Signature lost 20% of its deposits Friday as clients panicked at the collapse of SVB Finance Group fled to larger competitors.
The Readout with Allegra StrategionThe Readout with Allegra StrategionThe Readout with Allegra Strategy
The individual, who requested anonymity to discuss a private matter, did not provide precise figures on how much money left the bank. Signature stated in a Thursday statement that it had $89.2 trillion in deposits as of March 8. This would mean that $17.8billion was pulled in one day. According to a regulatory filing, this would mean that investors and depositors requested $42 billion in withdrawals at SVB’s Silicon Valley Bank Thursday.
Signature had $4.54 billion of cash in its balance sheet, and $26.4 billion in “marketable liquidity securities,” it stated last week in its statement.
These outflows, which were not previously reported, give a sense about the problems regulators and bank executives faced into the weekend as federal authorities tried to find liquidity solutions and reassure depositors.
Senator James Sanders, who is the Senate Banking Committee’s chair, said that the DFS was looking at closing Signature Bank. Sanders stated in an interview that “By Saturday, they saw a bank run, and they knew they had made a decision to move.”
According to the DFS, the decision to take control of the bank and turn it over to FDIC was made after it became clear that the bank would not be able to conduct business on Monday. Governor Kathy Hochul stated Monday that officials began monitoring the bank on Friday and continued to work through the weekend to find a solution.
Ran Eliasaf claimed he was one the depositors who withdrew money at Signature, a New York-based bank. Northwind Group is a New York-based commercial real estate private equity firm. It provides construction financing and short-term financing for multifamily homes, condos and senior-housing units.
Eliasaf, who was watching the fallout of SVB’s collapse at 10:30 a.m. on Friday, sent a message his team. He said that it was better to be safe than sorry and to move money to JPMorgan Chase & Co. or Bank of America Corp. as well as a few other smaller banks.