Tribunal rules against Home Office secrecy bid over Apple surveillance order

Companies, Business, Apple14 minutes ago

The UK government has failed in its attempt to maintain secrecy regarding a surveillance order issued to Apple, following a tribunal ruling that rejected the Home Office’s position. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal determined that the department’s efforts to avoid confirming or denying the existence of a technical capability notice were not justified. This legal development follows a challenge brought by the technology company after media reports revealed that the Home Office had sought access to encrypted data from the iPhone maker.

The tribunal dismissed the Home Office’s argument that public confirmation of the notice would damage national security. The judges found the government’s national security assessment to be flawed in a public law sense. They noted that the existence of the order is already widely known and can be easily retrieved through simple digital queries. Consequently, the tribunal concluded that confirming the notice in a legal setting does not introduce any new risk to national security. While the existence of the order is now a matter of public record, the specific technical details remain classified.

Apple, represented by legal counsel, initiated this second legal action after reports emerged that the Home Office had issued another notice seeking access to its encrypted data. This follows a previous incident where Whitehall withdrew an earlier order against the company after a diplomatic dispute with Washington. The government’s notice was served under the Investigatory Powers Act, legislation that permits the Home Secretary to compel tech companies to provide access to encrypted data. Apple refused to build a backdoor, arguing that weakening encryption for UK users would compromise its global security standards. The company also removed its advanced data protection feature from the UK market due to the ongoing dispute.

The tribunal criticised authorised leaks to The Times and The Financial Times, stating that these disclosures fatally undermined the government’s claim that official confirmation would harm national security. Home Office witnesses claimed that investigations into the media articles found no government source. However, the tribunal noted that the department failed to provide investigation reports, details of the steps taken, or witness statements from ministers denying they authorised the briefings. The judgment also detailed how the UK government authorised Apple to brief the US Vice President and Attorney General while restricting them from briefing Congress. It further cited public claims by former US Representative Tulsi Gabbard that the UK briefly backed down before issuing a fresh order.

Apple’s legal challenge to the surveillance powers, alongside a parallel challenge by Privacy International and Liberty, will proceed to a substantive hearing in the first half of 2027. Much of the proceedings will now be open to the public. This is not the first time the parties have been in court over this issue, as Apple launched a legal challenge against the Home Office last year following its first notice. That case was abandoned after diplomatic pushback from Washington led the Home Office to withdraw the global order. Apple and the Home Office have been contacted for comment.

Post Disclaimer

The following content has been published by Stockmark.IT. All information utilised in the creation of this communication has been gathered from publicly available sources that we consider reliable. Nevertheless, we cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of this communication.

This communication is intended solely for informational purposes and should not be construed as an offer, recommendation, solicitation, inducement, or invitation by or on behalf of the Company or any affiliates to engage in any investment activities. The opinions and views expressed by the authors are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of the Company, its affiliates, or any other third party.

The services and products mentioned in this communication may not be suitable for all recipients, by continuing to read this website and its content you agree to the terms of this disclaimer.

Our Socials

Recent Posts

Stockmark.1T logo with computer monitor icon from Stockmark.it
Loading Next Post...
Loading

Signing-in 3 seconds...

Signing-up 3 seconds...